Discover the Top Must-Try Dishes at Our Cuban Restaurant
Located in Old Town Key West, El Mesón de Pepe has been sharing genuine Cuban flavors for more than 40 years. This guide walks you through the standout dishes that define our kitchen—the recipes rooted in tradition, the small plates perfect for sharing, and the desserts that finish the meal on a sweet note. Whether you live here or are visiting, these picks will help you explore our menu and get the most from a meal with us. From hearty entrees to classic sweets, we’ll point out what to order and why it matters to our Cuban heritage.
Which signature Cuban dishes should you try?
Cuban cooking is all about bold, comforting flavors and honest ingredients. At El Mesón de Pepe you’ll find the classics done with care—each plate is built to showcase Cuba’s culinary traditions and the home-style techniques that make them so memorable.
Dish
Description
Key ingredients
Ropa vieja
Tender shredded beef simmered in a rich tomato-and-pepper sauce
Shredded beef, bell peppers, onions, tomatoes, spices
Cuban sandwich
A warm, pressed sandwich layered with roasted pork, ham and melted Swiss
Cuban bread, roasted pork, ham, Swiss cheese, pickles, mustard
Picadillo
A savory ground-beef hash brightened with olives and raisins
Ground beef, olives, raisins, tomatoes, spices
Why is ropa vieja considered Cuba’s national treasure?
Ropa vieja—literally “old clothes”—carries a long history and deep family roots. Originally from the Canary Islands, it became a Cuban favorite for good reason: slow-braised beef pulled into ribbons and cooked in a fragrant tomato base with peppers and onions. The long simmer brings all the flavors together, so every forkful is comforting and layered. It’s a dish that honors resilience, tradition and the simple joy of a well-made meal.
What makes our Cuban sandwich a Key West favorite?
The Cuban sandwich is a Key West staple—crunchy on the outside, warm and melty inside. We stack slow-roasted pork, ham, Swiss cheese, pickles and mustard on authentic Cuban bread, then press it to get that irresistible crisp exterior. It’s simple, balanced and exactly the kind of comforting sandwich that keeps locals and visitors coming back.
Traditional Cuban meals that define our cuisine
Traditional Cuban plates favor bold seasoning and hearty portions, shaped by Spain, Africa and the Caribbean. At El Mesón de Pepe you’ll taste recipes handed down through generations—dishes that celebrate familiar ingredients and honest cooking.
How is picadillo prepared to capture Cuban flavors?
Picadillo is a classic that balances savory and sweet. Our version sautés onions and bell peppers, then adds seasoned ground beef, tomatoes and a touch of cumin and oregano. A handful of olives and raisins brings bright, contrasting notes that make the dish feel comforting and complete—perfect over rice or with warm plantains.
What is special about our lechón asado and moros y cristianos?
Lechón asado—citrus-garlic marinated roast pork—is a centerpiece at Cuban gatherings. We marinate the pork in a mojo of garlic and citrus, then slow roast it until the meat is tender and the skin has a touch of crisp. Paired with moros y cristianos (black beans and white rice), the combo is classic Cuban: soulful, satisfying and built for sharing.
Cuban appetizers and desserts
Cuban meals begin and end with delicious small plates and sweets. At El Mesón de Pepe you’ll find appetizers that whet the appetite and desserts that round out the experience with authentic, homemade flavors.
Must-try appetizers: papa rellenas and tostones rellenos
Start with papa rellenas—mashed potatoes stuffed with seasoned ground beef, breaded and fried until golden—or tostones rellenos, twice-fried green plantains filled with savory options like shrimp or beef. These bites are perfect for sharing and showcase the textures and flavors that make Cuban appetizers so inviting.
How do our desserts and coffee complete your meal?
No Cuban meal is finished without dessert and strong coffee. Our flan is silky with caramel notes, and the tres leches cake comes moist and richly sponged in three milks. Pair either with a bold cup of Cuban coffee for the genuine finish—a sweet, warming way to end your meal.
Authentic food and a vibrant atmosphere
Eating at El Mesón de Pepe is as much about the vibe as the food. Our dining room buzzes with lively conversation, and the décor and music bring a touch of Cuba to Key West. It’s a welcoming spot for family meals, date nights and anything in between.
What role does live salsa music play?
Live salsa sets the tone: energetic, rhythmic and joyful. The music creates a festive backdrop that lifts the meal and invites guests to relax, clap along or simply enjoy the beat while they dine. It’s part of the full-sensory experience we offer.
Why is our location near Mallory Square perfect for sunset dining?
Just steps from Mallory Square, El Mesón de Pepe is ideally placed for sunset views. Come for dinner as the sky changes color and enjoy your meal with water and harbor sights nearby—a memorable setting that pairs beautifully with Cuban food and music. Learn more about Mallory Square and the Sunset Celebration, or grab a drink at our Patio Bar.
Private events with authentic Cuban cuisine
El Mesón de Pepe is a great choice for private events—from birthdays to corporate dinners. Our space and menus can be tailored to fit the tone and size of your gathering, so your guests leave impressed and well fed.
What services and spaces do we offer?
We offer customizable menus highlighting our signature Cuban dishes and flexible seating to suit intimate gatherings or larger parties. Our team handles details from menu planning to service, so you can focus on the celebration.
How to plan your event with us
Planning is simple: contact us or explore private parties to check dates, discuss menu options and note any special requests. We’ll work with you to create an event that reflects the warmth and flavor of Cuban culture—seamless and memorable from start to finish.
Frequently asked questions
What are the health benefits of traditional Cuban cuisine? Traditional Cuban food often features vegetables, lean proteins and legumes—think black beans and rice, which provide fiber and protein. Staples like garlic and cumin add flavor without relying on excess salt, and cooking methods like grilling or slow-roasting help preserve nutrients. Enjoyed in moderation, Cuban dishes can be a tasty part of a balanced diet.
Are there vegetarian or vegan options? Yes—we offer vegetarian and vegan choices. Many sides (black beans, rice, yuca) are naturally vegan, and items like tostones rellenos can be prepared with plant-based fillings. Let us know your preferences and we’ll help you find or adapt dishes to suit your diet.
What is the best time to visit for a lively atmosphere? Evenings—especially weekends with live salsa—are when the restaurant is most vibrant. Sunset service is also popular for the view and energy. If you prefer a quieter table, consider arriving earlier in the evening or asking for a less central seating area.
How can I make a reservation? Reservations are easy: call us or reach out through our website to check availability. We recommend reserving ahead during peak hours and weekends. If you have a large group or special requests, mention them when you book so we can accommodate you smoothly. You can also learn about priority seating.
What are the most popular desserts? Flan and tres leches cake are favorites—flan for its creamy caramel finish, and tres leches for its moist, indulgent texture. Both are classic choices that guests often pick to close out a meal.
Is El Mesón de Pepe family-friendly? Absolutely. We welcome guests of all ages. Our menu includes options for kids, high chairs are available, and our staff is happy to make family dining comfortable and enjoyable for everyone.
Conclusion
Eating at El Mesón de Pepe is a chance to taste authentic Cuban cooking while soaking up the lively Key West atmosphere. From ropa vieja to tres leches, our dishes celebrate tradition, flavor and the joy of shared meals. We’d love to see you soon—bring friends or family, enjoy the music, and savor the flavors. Make your reservation today and discover the spirit of Cuban dining in Key West.
Sign Up & Receive 10%* Off A fusion of Native American Taino food, Spanish, African and Caribbean cooking, Cuban cuisine has been a staple on the island of Key West for over a century. Being locat...
Cuban home cooking blends Spanish, African and Caribbean influences into a straightforward, ingredient‑forward cuisine built on slow braises, punchy marinades and citrus brighteners. This guide breaks...
Sign Up & Receive 10%* Off If you’re visiting Key West, there’s a wealth of food that you just don’t see regularly off the island. From a bounty of freshly caught seafood to the sweet and tart key...
Sign Up & Receive 10%* Off It’s a debate as old as time. Where did the Cuban sandwich ‘truly’ begin? Who makes the ‘most authentic one’? Where do you go to get one? What may be the best answer to...
